News

Graziers’ victory against mining giant Glencore Xstrata

Three central Queensland landowners celebrate a bittersweet win against Glencore Xstrata.
Three central Queensland landowners celebrate a bittersweet win against Glencore Xstrata. Contributed

AFTER courtroom scenes reminiscent of the classic Aussie battler tale, The Castle, three central Queensland landowners are celebrating a bittersweet win against mining giant Glencore Xstrata.

Xstrata Coal Queensland and its Japanese joint venture partners have been ordered to pay more than $30 million in compensation to the landholders within 30 days of the State Government granting mining leases over the $7 billion Wandoan thermal coal project.

The Land Court determination handed down by president Carmel MacDonald in Brisbane this month, awarded $11.38m to Cowan and Helen Keys.

The family trust Sky Grove Pty Ltd were awarded $11.338m for the acquisition of the grazing properties, AvonView and Langowan.

John Erbacher was ordered to be compensated $10.77m for East Lynne and Tamara.

East Lynne is used for beef production, dry land cropping and has a piggery.

Beef producers Thomas and Janice Edmonds, of Turraden, would receive about $8.31m.

The Wandoan greenfield project has been the target of constant speculation over its future after Glencore Xstrata pulled the plug on its $1billion Balaclava Island coal export terminal near Gladstone last month.

Landholders Services director George Houen represented the families and said it was a significant decision after the three stood firm while more than 35 other property owners buckled and sold privately to Xstrata.

"We are really pleased in terms of what courts normally award and it's a notable decision because it is a fair one to the landholders," Mr Houen said.

"The project was always going to require Xstrata to own all of the land and it chose to go about acquiring it in a way which brought about this situation.

"I guess they might now be reflecting on the stance they took because it was perfectly obvious they were not making a fair offer to the landholders they were trying to dispossess.

"But I don't think anybody thinks this mine is going ahead in the current (market) circumstances, so there's a period of real uncertainty ahead for the owners because it could be years before it goes ahead and that compensation becomes effective."

Ms MacDonald ignored submissions for a sunset clause and indexation to be imposed to the payouts if there were lengthy delays in granting the mining leases.

"There is no provision in the Act for the court to order that an award of compensation be indexed," Ms MacDonald said.

"If there is a long delay between the handing down of this decision and the grant of the mining leases, such that the rate of the award is eroded by inflation… the respondents may apply for a review of compensation on the grounds there has been a material change of circumstances.

"The Act requires the Land Court to determine compensation, not to decide when compensation might cease to be payable."

The compensation was determined on recent rural land sales in the area, and the court was told resource companies often paid well above book value to acquire properties of interest.

Topics:  glencore, grazier, xstrata




Join the Community.

Get your local news, your way.

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

John and Dee serve up taste of the sea in Rocky

Dee Jemmett and Joanna Duncan at Rocky Reef Seafood Deli. Photo Allan Reinikka / The Morning Bulletin

New seafood deli open in Rockhampton

BUDGET 2016: Small business tax cuts cost us $9 billion

Australian Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison speaks at the despatch box during the delivery of the 2016-17 Federal Budget in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra,

It will cost the federal government $5.3 billion in lost revenue

Did Federal Budget forget about Queensland?

Queensland Treasurer Curtis Pitt says we've been forgotten.

Queensland short-changed by at least $1 billion in federal budget

Latest deals and offers

Margaret Strelow - Capricorn Enterprise

Margaret Strelow returned as Rockhampton mayor. Photo Allan Reinikka / The Morning Bulletin

Rockhampton Regional mayor Margaret Strelow speaks about the ongoing funding...

DV Basketball

Rockets' Jordan Gregoryand Auryn Macmillan with Cyclones' Alice Kunek and Gabbi Clayton. Photo Allan Reinikka / The Morning Bulletin

Rockhampton basketball and police join forces to combat DV

Cr Ellen Smith - Planning Decision

ELECTION TIME: Ellen Smith is running for Division 4 in the upcoming Council election.

Councillor Ellen Smith speaks about a Rockhampton Regional Council decision to...

Real estate agent says new developments push area forward

ON THE UPSIDE: Shae O’Reilly says the Capricorn Coast and the wider region has plenty of projects going on while we wait for an outcome on Great Keppel Island.

"sentiment can’t hang its hat on one setback for one project"

Real estate reveals Rocky's rising suburbs

Pat O'Driscoll Real Estate sales consultant Talitha Dodson Photo: Contributed

Talitha Dodson says it’s not all doom and gloom

Demand for acreage lots pushes up property prices

Property values in Cooroy have increased 25%

Property values jump in Cooroy and Peachester.