Consumer advocacy group Choice has scored four dishwashing liquid brands 'the same as water'. Supplied by Choice
Consumer advocacy group Choice has scored four dishwashing liquid brands 'the same as water'. Supplied by Choice

Dud dishwashing liquids ‘same as water’

Consumer advocacy group Choice has scored four "woeful" dishwashing liquid brands "the same as water".

It tested 38 popular products using identically pre-soiled plates stained with different foods, including rice starch, bolognese and egg yolk, and also washed with plain water to compare cleaning performance.

Four products scored a shocking 45 per cent - the same result as unadulterated H2O.

They were Fairy Platinum, Palmolive Original, Uniquely Natural and Woolworths Essential.

"With results this poor, you're really just washing money down the drain," Choice dishwashing expert Ashley Iredale said.

"And some of these products aren't cheap either - Uniquely Natural costs 96c per 100ml and Fairy Platinum a whopping $1.12."

There were two clear winners that shone the brightest, with Morning Fresh Ultra Concentrate Ultimate and Aldi Tandil Ultra Power Soak n' Clean Concentrate in equal first place, rating 90 per cent.

These two beat others ‘by a mile’. Picture: Supplied by Choice
These two beat others ‘by a mile’. Picture: Supplied by Choice

"Both products rated very well and outperformed other liquids in the test by a mile - the next closest score was 65 per cent," Ms Iredale said.

"But when it comes to price, Aldi Tandil easily wins on value at just 35c per 100ml compared with Morning Fresh's 93c."

Choice said Aldi Tandil was also safe for greywater and septic tanks and used biodegradable surfactants, unlike Morning Fresh.

Aldi Tandil Ultra Concentrate landed third place with a score of 65 per cent.

Four other products scored 60 per cent: Morning Fresh Ultra Concentrate Botanicals, Morning Fresh Ultra Concentrate Original, Woolworths Shine Sensations, and Simply Clean Australian Lemon Myrtle.

Choice says these brands were the worst performers. Picture: Supplied by Choice
Choice says these brands were the worst performers. Picture: Supplied by Choice

Choice said it was interesting that popular products such as Palmolive, Fairy, Earth Choice, Sunlight, Orange Power and Ecostore rated just 55 per cent.

Aldi clearly cleaned up in the battle of supermarket house brands, while Woolworths' highest scorer Shine Sensations only achieved 60 per cent, Coles' Super Strength liquid landed 55 per cent and IGA's Community Co Clean Freak Concentrate scored a measly 50 per cent.

Choice said the quality of a brand's range could vary greatly between products, with Morning Fresh Ultra Concentrate "Antibacterial" and "Soft Hands Fragrance and Dye Free" rating only 50 per cent.

"Our tests uncovered some wild variation, so never assume that if one product cleans well, similar ones will deliver the same results," Ms Iredale said.

"It's worth keeping in mind when you're shopping - otherwise you could grab an inferior product accidentally.

"Likewise, don't assume an expensive product will outperform a cheap one."

Originally published as Dud dishwashing liquids 'same as water'



WATCH: Incredible rescue of woman from Fitzroy River drain

Premium Content WATCH: Incredible rescue of woman from Fitzroy River drain

With the tide incoming, darkness falling and no way of reaching the woman, a...

Man attends DV victim’s house after watch-house release

Premium Content Man attends DV victim’s house after watch-house release

He attended the address about one hour after signing release conditions from...

Steer prices soar to uncharted territory at cattle sale

Premium Content Steer prices soar to uncharted territory at cattle sale

A Droughtmaster cross pen fetched 710.2c/kg, breaking the facility’s cents per kilo...