Is a fat woman suitable for an anti-smoking health ad?

Kathy Sundstrom
Kathy Sundstrom

IS AN overweight woman really the best pin-up the Australian Government could come up with for its latest anti-smoking campaign?  

I understand the campaign, flashed across our television screens nightly, is trying to target the horrendous smoking figures in Indigenous people.  

I understand it is trying to pull at heart strings as the woman talks about the family she has lost and she is obviously meant to come across as a "real person".  

But when the Australian Indigenous Health Info Net lists Type 2 diabetes as "one of the most important health problems for Indigenous populations across Australia", perhaps the advert is fundamentally flawed?  

Arguably, diabetes is more of a health problem in Australia than smoking.  

It is certainly becoming more of a challenge to address.  

A fat woman (sorry, but I'm going to say it like it is) talking about the health risks of smoking would be like a thin person talking about weight while lighting up.  

A National Tobacco Campaign in 1999 found anti-smoking campaigns targeting Indigenous people weren't that effective, but may have more power if delivered by an Indigenous elder.    

I checked with the health department if the woman in the campaign was an elder speaking from the heart, or a paid model reading a script.  

"The woman in the commercial is an actor who has been incorporated to tell a story that is common in many Indigenous families," a health spokeswoman said.  

The ad was tested and found the woman to be "a strong role model for Indigenous people".   

Topics:  opinion smoking weight

Dash cam footage captures motorway chaos

DASH cam footage has emerged of a dramatic three car pileup on a South East Queensland on ramp heading to the Sunshine Coast.

Epic three car pile-up caught on camera

Community rallies behind sons of mum who drowned in Emu Park

Tracey Williams died saving her son from the water in Emu Park.

THOUSANDS already raised as family prepares for life without Tracey

Yeppoon girls' a-lure-ing start in the workforce

L-R DeeAnn Busby, Maggie McLaughlin, Taylor Lanigan, Samantha O'Brien.

CQ girls leave behind home to pursue their dreams in the "big city”

Local Partners