News

Gable Tostee murder trial: Jury can't reach verdict

THE jury deliberating in the case of Gable Tostee have been unable to reach a unanimous verdict.

The jury sent Justice John Byrne a note just after 3pm local time informing him.

Justice Byrne ordered jurors to return to the jury room, in a bid to reach a verdict.

"Experience has shown that juries can often agree if given enough time to consider and discuss the issues," he said.

"But if after calmly considering the evidence and listening to the opinions of other jurors, you cannot honestly agree with the conclusions of others, then you must give effect to your own view of the evidence.

"Each of you has sworn or affirmed you will conscientiously try the charges and decide them, according to the evidence.

"That is an important responsibility. Each of you takes into the jury room your individual experience and wisdom and you are expected to judge the evidence fairly and impartially in that light."

Tostee is on trial in the Brisbane Supreme Court for the murder of Kiwi Warriena Wright, who plummeted to her death from his Surfers Paradise apartment during a Tinder date in August 2014.

Earlier on Tuesday, jurors asked further questions of Justice Byrne, seeking clarification on two points surrounding the removal of Warriena Wright by Tostee from his apartment and onto his balcony.

In the first question, jurors asked at which point on the audio recording Tostee made is he regarded as removing a disorderly person from his property.

Tostee's defence barrister Saul Holt, QC, argued that Tostee was acting within his legal right to remove a disorderly person from his property, when he forcibly put Ms Wright on the balcony and shut the door, moments before she plunged to her death while attempting to climb to the balcony underneath on August 8, 2014.

"It does not matter when," Justice Byrne answered.

"You must find the accused not guilty of both murder and manslaughter unless you are satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused used more force than necessary in removing Warriena Wright from his unit."

The jury - six men and six women - also asked if Tostee putting Ms Wright on his balcony constituted removing her from his property.

Justice Byrne's reply was brief.

"Yes," he answered.

The jury was then sent back to continue their deliberations, before returning with yet another note - this time saying it could not reach a verdict.

Justice Byrne earlier instructed jurors that Wright's level of drunkenness on the night she plunged to her death is a factor they must consider when determining if the decision she made to climb over Tostee's balcony was a rational one.

Jurors deliberating in Tostee's murder trial passed Justice Byrne a note on Monday afternoon, asking four questions, including if Ms Wright's level of intoxication when she died was a factor they must take into account when determining if her decision to climb over Tostee's balcony was rational and reasonable.

In the Brisbane Supreme Court on Tuesday morning, Justice Byrne said it was a factor they must consider when determining if Tostee unlawfully killed his Tinder date, on August 8, 2014.

"A jury of your accumulated experience of life scarcely needs a judge to point out that excessive consumption of alcohol can impair judgement ... People, when drunk do things, they would not when sober," he said.

"The degree of Warriena Wright's intoxication when the accused moved her onto the balcony has potential to bear on your consideration as to whether the decision to climb over the balcony was a reasonable and rational or proportionate response to the accused's conduct.

"Her state of mind should be taken into account, the extent to which her decision to climb over the balcony was reasonable, rational and proportionate, in response to the conduct of the accused."

Crown prosecutor Glenn Cash argued Ms Wright chose to climb the balcony due to her "abject fear" of Tostee, while defence counsel Saul Holt, QC, argued Tostee locked Ms Wright out on the balcony to de-escalate the violet situation in the apartment, in which Ms Wright had repeatedly attacked him.

Justice Byrne also instructed jurors that a metal object CCTV footage captured Tostee carrying when he exited the lift of his apartment building after Ms Wright's death is irrelevant to their deliberations.

He said what Tostee had in his hand after Ms Wright's death had no bearing on their verdict, reminding them of his earlier direction that Tostee's conduct after Ms Wright's fatal fall should not be considered as pointing to his guilt.

"There is no evidence beyond the CCTV of the item you have asked about," he said.

"Neither of the final addresses sought to make anything of what you could see on the CCTV footage after Ms Wright's death. Neither party speculated.

"Finally, I remind you of my direction you cannot give Mr Tostee's conduct after Ms Wright fell as in any way advancing the prosecution case on murder or manslaughter."

Tostee has pleaded not guilty to murder.

The jury may also find a lesser charge of manslaughter.

- NZ Herald

Topics:  editors picks gable tostee jury murder trial



Six hideaway bars to escape winter chill

THE last season of GoT finally uttered the words we’ve been waiting six seasons to hear and now that the weather has cooled down in Brisbane, “winter is here.”

Our six art gallery picks for a creative day out

Queensland's Gallery of Modern Art always has a fun, exciting and interesting exhibition on show for the whole family to enjoy.

YOU'D be mistaken in thinking Brisbane wasn't an arty city.

Brisbane's arts and culture events centre stage

You loved the film, now you're about to love the musical. Don't miss The Bodyguard The Musical in Brisbane this July.

THE arts and culture events you don't want to miss.

Homewares stores to fulfil your Instagram dreams

No Caption

You too can become an Insta-star with these fab stores.

Date nights under $50

Nothing is more romantic than a picnic with a cracking view.

NOT every date has to cost you a bomb.

Top 10 Brisbane experiences to cross off your bucket list

Do yourself a favour and get amongst the food truck scene. Eat Street is a great place to start.

A GOOD bucket list doesn’t have to span continents or cost millions.

Six mega sporting events you need to be at this year

Don't miss all the action trackside this season.

IF THERE is one thing Brisbane does damn well, it’s play host.

Drunk driver reversed car into another and fled scene

Shannon Lee Mountford pleaded guilty in the Rockhampton Magistrates Court on Monday for reversing a motor vehicle when it was not safe to, failing to give her details to the other motorist and failing to provide a breath specimen to police.

Driver refused to give police breath sample three times that night

Rocky mum tries 'not to panic' as husband isolated

Jasmine Schneider was told yesterday the possibility her husband, Greg, had meningococcal was on the table.

ROCKY mum told her husband would be tested for deadly disease.

Major announcement as shopping giant given approval in Rocky

ALDI Property director Brendan Geary, Mayor Margaret Strelow and Cr Ellen Smith announce plans for new Rockhampton ALDI stores back in February.

HUGELY popular shopping giant to build Rocky store at this location.

Local Partners

Exporting our kitchen skills

ROCKHAMPTON'S newest export market is the sharing of culinary skills for the preparation of Asian Fusion style meals with international visitors.


Win a $1000

GROCERY GIFT CARD!
Learn More

No horsing around in wild west spectacular

The Rooftop Express Wild West Show is expected to thrill audiences at the Rockhampton Heritage Festival, with a show produced specially for the Beef Capital.

Beef Capital to be wowed by Rooftop Express at Heritage Festival

Musical favourite hits the Rockhampton stage

STEPPING UP: The new kid Ren, played by Joseph Lewis with the town folk (from left) Ben Childes, Jack Kelly, Patrick Reddy, Mackenzie Ralphs and Nicholas Marxsen. Footloose will hit the Pilbeam Theatre Stage Friday, May 26 and Saturday May 27.

The Cathedral College gets 'Footloose'

ACROSS THE REGION: Your weekend of events in CQ

STAGE: The Cathedral College presents Footloose at the Pilbeam Theatre on Friday and Saturday.

Find out what's happening across CQ right here.

Air show hits great heights

Thousands of aviation fans were propelled through the gates of 'The Old Station' near Raglan, to witness the 26th The Old Station Fly In and Heritage Show.

Shock Rocky announcement fuels online anger

RIDING ON: Rockhampton Show-goers enjoy the spinning Coaster ride at the 2016 show.

Issues identified with pre-paid ticket bundles, two weeks from show

Wonder Woman is a kick-arse superhero romp

Wonder Woman may just redeem DC yet

Wine and dine with the experts

CHEERS: get along to Headricks Lane on Saturday 3rd June for a wine lunch with a difference, presented by South Australian Winemaker Greg Cooley of Greg Cooley Wines.

SA Winemaker Greg Cooley of Greg Cooley Wines visits Rockhampton.

The hefty costs for cheering on our Maroons

HYPED: Gabby Dargel (left) and her partner Nathaniel Spreadborough are planning a road trip to see the State of Origin in Brisbane.

Gabby Dargel is spitting chips over the cost of flights to Origin

Everything coming to Netflix, Stan, Foxtel and Amazon Prime Video this June

Orange Is The New Black returns for another season.

Find out what's being added to our streaming services in June.

Sam Armytage and Tom Cruise? Saaaaay what?

Apparently, the answer is no.

New $46.7m counter-terrorism facility to be built in Wacol

Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk, pictured with Police Commisioner Ian Stewart, has announced plans to build a new counter-terrorism facility in Wacol.

The facility will be built over three years.

Home to a sex worker: Sordid history of iconic Coast shed

Milojevic Djordjevic's daughter Linda at the derelict shed on Yandina-Coolum Road.

The shed was once a liveable 'barrack'.

This is real estate's billion-dollar man

Bob Wolff at AREC with John McGrath of McGrath Real Estate.

They don’t call him the “Billion dollar man” for nothing

Man's amazing comeback from monster crisis

Pat O'Driscoll agents Penny Keating and Doug Webber sold 56 Agnes St, The Range at auction over the weekend.

NOT long ago, he sold his possessions to pay staff. Now he's back.

Deluge brings massive price rise for property near Rocky

BIG BUY: The Howard family handed over Yaamba's historic Balmoral property to the Harvey family on Thursday.

DOWNPOUR'S perfect timing entices buyer to pay huge dollars.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!