OPINION: ‘Mistake of fact’ defence rape laws need balance

AS a sexual assault victim, I struggle listening to rape cases before the court, not just because it reminds me of my own experiences, but also because my heart fills with sadness for what the victims have to go through to get justice.

But that doesn't mean I support the proposed abolishment of the 110-year-old 'mistake of fact' defence available in Queensland for rape defendants. Nor do I support it in its current form.

The rape trial that ran in Rockhampton this week is a good example of why 'mistake of fact' defence should stay.

I feel sorry for the woman who had to give evidence in this trial because that is not an easy task.

But I can, after listening to the closing addresses which pointed to evidence put to the jury thoughout the week, see how that young man may not have realised how intoxicated the woman was, nor know she was 'blacking out' after swallowing an illicit drug.

From what I heard, there was no suggestion he knew she had swallowed the pill.

I don't believe there was any 'victim blaming' in this case. Just questions raised about how a young man with little life experience and intoxicated himself could have known her state of mind if she wasn't displaying behaviour that suggested she was too intoxicated to give consent.

I do hope the Law Reform Commission's recommendations are able to update this law to modern standards, while finding a balance of knocking those that abuse the justice system using this defence and those accused when they genuinely thought they were having consensual sex.



Longreach council puts student hostel on the market

Premium Content Longreach council puts student hostel on the market

The facility has been closed since 2015 due to low enrolment numbers.

Yeppoon sculpture gets Australian Street Art Award

Premium Content Yeppoon sculpture gets Australian Street Art Award

Queensland took home a third of the awards from the national awards.

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Wisdom does not always come with age

Premium Content LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Wisdom does not always come with age

Harry Bruce’s cartoon of the day and readers have their say on current events.